Skip to content
TR Register
This page belongs to a past congress. 1st International Emergency Aid and Disaster Management Congress Go to the current congress

Abstract Evaluation Criteria

1st International Emergency Aid and Disaster Management Congress

QUANTITATIVE RESEARCH EVALUATION CRITERIA

1. Is the study topic original?

  • Not original (0 points)
  • Partially original (3 points)
  • Original (5 points)

2. Does the title of the study reflect the content and method of the study?

  • No (0 points)
  • Yes, partially (3 points)
  • Yes, completely (5 points)

3. Are the purpose and/or research question of the study and hypotheses (if any) clearly stated?

  • No (0 points)
  • Yes, partially (3 points)
  • Yes, completely (5 points)

4. Are the people included in the study specified? (if any, inclusion or exclusion criteria)

  • No (0 points)
  • Yes, partially (3 points)
  • Yes, completely (5 points)

5. Are the place, time, and design (type of study) of the study specified?

  • No (0 points)
  • Yes, partially (3 points)
  • Yes, completely (5 points)

6. Is the study design appropriate for the study?

  • Not appropriate (0 points)
  • Partially appropriate (3 points)
  • Fully appropriate (5 points)

7. Have the universe, sample size, and sampling method of the study been specified?

  • No (0 points)
  • Yes, partially (3 points)
  • Yes, completely (5 points)

8. Have the data collection methods of the study been specified?

  • No (0 points)
  • Yes, partially (3 points)
  • Yes, completely (5 points)

9. Have the (dependent-independent) variables of the study been specified?

  • No (0 points)
  • Yes, partially (3 points)
  • Yes, completely (5 points)

10. Have the statistical methods used in the study been specified?

  • Not appropriate (0 points)
  • Partially appropriate (3 points)
  • Fully appropriate (5 points)

11. Are the findings written in line with the objectives of the study?

  • No (0 points)
  • Yes, partially (3 points)
  • Yes, completely (5 points)

12. Are the findings presented understandably and include the results of the statistical analysis?

  • No (0 points)
  • Yes, partially (3 points)
  • Yes, completely (5 points)

13. Are the possible sources of bias and/or limitations of the study stated?

  • No (0 points)
  • Yes, partially (3 points)
  • Yes, completely (5 points)

14. Are recommendations based on the study results made?

  • No (0 points)
  • Yes, partially (3 points)
  • Yes, completely (5 points)

15. Is the study written understandably?

  • No (0 points)
  • Yes, partially (3 points)
  • Yes, completely (5 points)

16. What is the contribution of the study to the field of emergency aid and disaster management?

  • No contribution (0 points)
  • Limited contribution (5 points)
  • Contribution (10 points)
  • Total contribution (25 points)